10 Best Places To Sell Beanie Babies To Make Extra Money

Want to know where to sell Beanie Babies for the most money? Here’s how you can find out how much your Beanie Babies are worth as well as the best places to sell your Beanie Babies.

Back in the 1990s, Beanie Babies were all the rage. These small stuffed animals filled with plastic pellets were created by Ty Warner and became a huge craze in the mid-90s. If you have Beanie Babies lying in a box somewhere, you may wonder if you can make extra income with them.

In this post you’ll learn:

• Best places to sell beanie babies
• How to find out how much your beanie babies are worth
• What are some of the most valuable beanie babies
• The best way to sell beanie babies

Now, at one point many years ago, there were many valuable Beanie Babies. However, that isn’t really the case anymore. Most Beanie Babies aren’t worth anything, but it couldn’t hurt to check just in case you have something of high value (we can all dream, right?!).

10

This free workshop will teach you how to get into the flipping business. It will teach you how to resell furniture, electronics, appliances, and anything else you can find.

Where To Sell Beanie Babies For Cash

Here are the 10 best places to sell beanie babies.

1. eBay

The best place to sell your Beanie Babies is eBay. This is because eBay has a large customer base, a collectors’ market, and an auction option. You can also see what Beanie Babies have sold for in the past through past listings.

eBay also has policies in place to protect sellers in case of disputes or issues with buyers. This can give you peace of mind that other online marketplaces may not provide. eBay also makes it easy to calculate shipping costs with various shipping carriers, and you can even print shipping labels directly from the platform.

Before you publish your Beanie Baby listings on eBay, take high-quality photos from multiple angles and provide a description of everything to know about the Beanie Baby, including name, any errors if any, condition, and rarity.

2. Sell2BBNovelties

Sell2BBNovelties is an online platform that buys your stuff, including Beanie Babies. Once you’re on their site, you can do a quick search for Beanie Babies and see what they are buying and for how much.

When I do a quick search on Sell2BBNoveltities, I see they’re buying Beanie Babies like:

• TY Beanie Baby #1 Bear (only given to employees, signed and numbered) for $1,500
• TY Beanie Baby Chef Robuchon the Bear for $3,000
• TY Beanie Baby Coral Casino the Bear for $1,000
• TY Beanie Baby Billionaire Bear #2 for $600

Selling2BBNovelties works by finding an item they want to buy from you. After they confirm your sell order via email, you’ll ship your items to Selling2BBNovelties for evaluation. Then, they’ll confirm and pay you within 1 week of receipt.

3. Craigslist

Selling Beanie Babies on Craigslist is a good idea as Collectors frequent the site for items. To get started selling your Beanie Babies on Craigslist, take the following steps:

1. Write a detailed listing including condition, information about the tags, price, if you’re open to offers, and any other notable features.
2. Research the current market value price by checking online platforms like eBay.
3. Put your listing under the categories collectibles or toys.
4. Once you find a buyer, choose a safe place to meet like a police station parking lot, coffee shop, or public parking lot.

To successfully sell anything on Craigslist, it’s important to be honest and transparent.

4. Facebook Marketplace

Facebook Marketplace is a great spot to sell Beanie Babies because you have access to people locally and from around the country.

When creating your listing, make it clear if you’re looking to sell locally or willing to ship your Beanie Babies. Facebook Marketplace also has certain seller protections in place that provide an added layer of security for sellers by facilitating safe and traceable transactions.

You can also get more interest in your Beanie Babies by joining Beanie Baby Facebook groups that allow posting of Beanie Babies you’re looking to sell. You can also join these groups to get an idea of what your Beanie Babies currently sell for. It’s also handy to use keywords like “collector’s item”, “retired Beanie Babies” or anything else you think people may be looking for when searching for Beanie Babies to buy.

5. Etsy

Etsy is a popular online marketplace for unique, vintage, and collectible items. This makes Etsy a great platform for Beanie Babies.

If you have multiple Beanie Babies to sell, this is a great platform to sell on, especially if you already have a profile set up with 5-star reviews. People are more likely to buy from your Etsy store if you have good reviews in place already.

To get started selling on Etsy, you’ll need to have an account and create a compelling listing. A great title idea would be something like, “Vintage Retired Beanie Babie with tags intact” and a description that includes the condition, rarity of the item, and any special features.

6. OfferUp 

OfferUp is a user-friendly mobile app that connects sellers and buyers to sell things locally.

This method of selling your Beanie Babies is different from the other options listed because most of the selling is done through the mobile app and encourages in-person transactions, as well as certain safety features like verified identities.

The app OfferUp also allows sellers and buyers to leave reviews based on their experiences. Positive reviews make it easier to sell things since people are more trustworthy of someone with good reviews.

7. Mercari

Mercari is similar to OfferUp as it specializes in selling and buying items through a mobile app. The app is incredibly user-friendly and easy to use making it very simple to create a listing and get started selling. Mercari also helps with nationwide shipping by providing shipping labels.

The app also has a messaging system in place so you can easily message people who are interested in your items. Buyers can also make offers on items and negotiate prices. Mercari has a secure payment processing system and also occasionally has promotions and discounts to increase buying and selling on the app.

8. Flea market

You may want to try selling your Beanie Babies at a local flea market to reach local buyers.

You’ll need to get a table or booth space at a flea market where you can display your Beanie Babies. If you have a lot of Beanie Babies to choose from, it’s a good idea to organize by type, series, or theme to make it easier for buyers to go through.

It’s important to be friendly and approachable at flea markets as people are more likely to visit your booth or table if they feel welcomed. You can also try having deals or discounts if people buy Beanie Babies in bulk. Be prepared to accept cash at flea markets but also consider payment options like Zelle, Venmo, PayPal, or credit and debit cards.

9. Antique shops

If you have antique shops in your area, it’s worth it to give them a call to see if they’re interested in carrying Beanie Babies. If so, ask if they are interested in purchasing or cosigning the Beanie Babies. Be prepared to give the antique shop information about your Beanie Babies, including names, condition, rarity, if tags are intact, and any other special features.

You’ll also need to discuss price and terms with the antique shop. You need to research the value of your Beanie Babies before giving them away. Once you meet with the antique shop owner, they’ll want to agree to terms on the selling price, commission percentage, payment schedule, and duration of the consignment period.

I have personally seen Beanie Babies for sale at antique shops, but they usually are not rare and are not worth much. But, if you have a lot for sale, you may be able to see if you can put them all up for sale in one place in a local antique shop near you.

10. Yard sale

Selling Beanie Babies at a yard sale is a great way to de-clutter and get rid of Beanie Babies right away. Keep in mind you likely won’t get top prices for your Beanie Babies since you’re reaching a small local crowd (probably around a dollar or less per stuffed animal).

Here are some tips to have a successful yard sale.

• Choose a weekend with good weather
• Put up signage around town in areas where people will see the address and date clearly
• Post in local Facebook groups that share the date and address of your garage sale
• Make customers feel more comfortable by playing music and having refreshments

Frequently Asked Questions About Where To Sell Beanie Babies

Below are answers to common questions about where to sell beanie babies for cash.

How do I find out what my Beanie Babies are worth?

Finding out how much your beanie babies are worth is easy. Here’s an easy step-by-step guide to get a rough estimate:

1. Check out sites like eBay and Etsy to get an idea of the current market prices of your Beanie Baby. 
2. Look up completed listings on eBay to see what similar Beanie Babies sold for.
3. Wear and tear or damage can significantly reduce the value (For example, is the item dirty or in mint condition? Are there any odors or stains? Do you still have the hang tag intact?)
4. Join Beanie Baby collector groups on Facebook and get insight on the value of your Beanie Baby there. You could even make a post in one of these groups and ask people what they think it’s worth.

It’s important to keep in mind the value of Beanie Babies fluctuates over time based on market demand and trends. 

When did Beanie Babies lose their value?

Beanie Babies started losing their values in the late 90’s. This is due to many things such as:

• Overproduction of Beanie Babies, making them less rare and valuable
• Collectors were buying Beanie Babies in large quantities, and it eventually became clear the market was saturated.
• As trends came and went, interest in Beanie Babies decreased as new toys came on the market.

What are some valuable beanie babies?

Most Beanie Babies are no longer worth much, but a few of the rarest Beanie Babies can still make good cash among collectors. Here are some examples:

• Peanut the Royal Blue Elephant
• Valentino and Valentina Bears
• Princess the Bear
• Claude the Crab
• Peace Bear
• Humphrey the Camel
• Lefty the Donkey and Righty the Elephant

Are any Beanie Babies from the 90s worth anything?

Some Beanie Babies from the 90s are worth money. The factors that can make Beanie Babies valuable include:

• Rare or limited edition Beanie Babies like Valentino, Princess, or Peace Bear
• Design or tags with manufacturing errors
• Beanie Babies with first-generation tags
• Unusual colors due to manufacturing variations 
• Limited distribution Beanie Babies
• Beanie Babies were highly popular in the 90s, including certain animal designs or themed releases. 

Is it worth selling Beanie Babies? 

If you have Beanie Babies at home and they are sitting around getting dusty or dirty, it might be worth it to sell them especially if they’re worth some money. If your Beanie Babies are in good condition and have high market demand, they may be worthy of selling.

However, you also need to think about the effort vs. return when selling your Beanie Babies. This process can take a lot of time and effort so you need to think about the potential profit with your time and resources. 

If your Beanie Babies hold a lot of sentimental value for you or your family, you may prefer to keep them rather than sell them.

Which Beanie Babies are collectors looking for?

Collectors often look for rare, limited edition, or unique feature Beanie Babies. The market has declined A LOT since the 1990s, but some Beanie Babies still hold their value. Some Beanie Babies collectors are looking for include:

• Early generation Beanie Babies with first-generation tags
• Limited edition Beanie Babies that were produced in limited quantities
• Special edition Beanie Babies that were part of a holiday release or collaboration with an organization or event
• Beanie Babies produced with rare colors or variations
• Beanie Babies with tag errors including misspellings or unique tag variations
• Retired Beanie Babies that were retired from production early in their lifespan
• Themed collections or Beanie Babies with historical significance

Best Places To Sell Beanie Babies – Summary

I hope you enjoyed this article on the best places to sell beanie babies for cash.

Selling your Beanie Babies is a great idea if they’re worth money and have no sentimental value to you. Certain Beanie Babies can sell for money on sites like eBay and Etsy, so it’s important to research and see what you can make for your Beanie Babies.

TY products can sometimes be of value, especially if there is no dirt or smoke smell on them, to potential buyers for specific beanie babies.

I loved Beanie Babies as a kid, but I didn’t save a single one. I do sometimes wonder if I could have made some money with them.

Good luck and I hope you have something of high value!

Do you have beanie babies you want to sell?

Recommended reading: